I want to thank Chris Brown for the following review. Mr. Brown is a familiar member of the conculture/conlanger community. See his collection of tales called Theatre of the Mind, which I reviewed. I think he really "gets" my intentions for The Termite Queen! The book fails for any reader who isn't fascinated and compelled by the character of Griffen Gwidian, and it also fails if the mythic implications of the ends of Parts 3 and 4 aren't recognized. And if you aren't entertained by Kaitrin's narration of the Cyclops episode for the Queen and her entourage, something is the matter with you! LOL
Here is the review:
Here is the review:
The Champion and the Seer Receive the Speaking of the Dead |
Lorinda J. Taylor does
indeed take us on a wonderful literary sci-fi adventure. It is not a typical
"technology" based story she tells. There are certainly advanced trains (on
Earth) and space ships that take us between planets and advanced sciences; but
the story is not about those things. The technology is there, but doesn't take
center stage. Taylor gives just enough description of this far future world, its
technology and history to set the stage; then lets her characters act out the
story. It really is the story of people -- humans and off-worlders alike --
engaged in the whole gamut of sophont existence. From the highs of the quest for
new knowledge to the depths of jealousy and hatred of what is not understood,
Taylor gives us a well and rather tightly woven web of story.
I am
definitely nòt a fan of romances, but even so, I found the story of growing and
deepening love between Kaitrin and Gwidian to be a most compelling one, and
Taylor was certainly able to hold my interest throughout the ups and downs of
this part of the story. Taylor certainly demonstrates how a love story can be
more than satisfyingly written without having to rely on the crutch of
over-worked sex scenes as its only means of conveying the story. I even found
Kaitrin's post-adventure quest to understand Gwidian to be a rather compelling
story in and of itself. I think I read the last third of the book in one sitting
-- perhaps if for no other reason than to at last understand this Gwidian --
initially a bit of a snoot, and always a bit standoffish, but also somehow
desperately in need of love.
For me, the most interesting story line was
the doings of the Shshi -- the Termites -- themselves. How human, and yet how
other! Taylor deftly shows us a people who are both highly instinctual in their
behavior, as one might expect of social insects, but also very intelligent and
capable of overcoming the strong bonds of instinct. We see the extremes of
absolute faith and sense of duty contrasted with base desire for power and
authority, as embodied in the struggle between the Seer and the Chamberlain.
Both truly believe they are working for the good of their people, but the one
seeks to do the will of the Termite's nameless mother goddess, while the other
seeks to serve his own will by throwing the whole place into a cunningly planned
coup. The result (good wins, by the way!) might be predictable, but as we read,
this outcome is anything but secure and indeed could have turned out rather
differently at any number of points along the way.
The whole of the story
is also high and sacred myth retold. We find nods to the Mabinogi, classical
Greek myth and the New Testament as well. Of the former, some aspects of
Gwidian's life mirror the old Welsh tales. Kaitrin's retelling of the Polyphemus
episode from Odyssey for her Termite audience is a real hoot and requires a good
bit of cross-cultural gymnastics. Always a bit of an enigma for Taylor's 30th
century, post-religious, humanistic and generally agnostic humans, the Nameless
One -- the Creator as she is known by the Shshi -- and her communion with her
Termite children comes across very well from the Termite perspective. Here we
find several nods to the New Testament, including the sacramental nature of the
Termites' nectar and how the goddess describes humans as 'not knowing what they
believe'; and thus she must resort to vaguish signs to communicate with them
rather than the more direct visions she uses with the in many respects more
innocent Shshi. It struck me as an interesting parallel to the teaching of Jesus
that one must go to the Heavenly Father "as a child" (i.e., with innocence and
openness) and this pretty well describes the Shshi vis-a-vis the Mother. They
have a kind of innate openness and innocence and acceptance that I think humans
lack. Very nicely done!
Altogether, I'd say that both volumes of Termite
Queen constitute a good read and I highly recommend it.
No comments:
Post a Comment